99 The Loneliest Profession? Why Employer Brand Needs Its Own Community | Crystal Lay (PBC)
In this episode of the VideoMy Pod’s US Series, host David Macciocca and co-host Bryan Chaney, founder of People Nerd and People Brand Collective (PBC), sit down with one of PBC's co-founders, Crystal Lay, to explore a topic that doesn’t get nearly enough airtime: the isolation, lack of standards, and professional fragmentation facing employer brand and people communications practitioners today — and what’s being done about it.
Drawing on over two decades in the industry, including stints in marketing, HR, consulting, and agency work, Crystal shares why employer brand professionals are among the loneliest in the workforce, why the industry is about 10 years behind traditional marketing in terms of maturity and structure, and why she and Brian set out to build something bigger than a conference or a Slack group. She also gets into what makes a community genuinely work, why PBC deliberately includes agencies, vendors, and consultants as equals, and what it would mean for the industry to finally have its own professional standards, research, and advocacy body.
For anyone working in employer brand, recruitment marketing, or people communications (whether you’re a team of one or part of a larger function) this episode will resonate deeply and might just make you feel a little less alone.
Key Topics:
02:00 – Crystal’s background: from marketing to recruiting to 20+ years in employer brand
06:00 – The epidemic of loneliness and why it’s hitting EB practitioners especially hard
10:00 – Why EB and people brand professionals are the “redheaded stepchildren” of every industry group
14:00 – The gap PBC is trying to fill: no professional home, no standards, no advocacy
18:00 – Why PBC includes agencies, vendors, and consultants as equal members — not second-class ones
22:00 – Consultant speak, individual identity, and remembering your personal value
25:30 – Who disproportionately ends up outside corporate roles — and why that matters
28:00 – What community success actually looks like: Dunbar’s theory and the deeper metrics
31:00 – Creating industry standards, original research, and a living knowledge base
33:30 – How PBC services members globally across time zones and learning formats
34:30 – Why employer brand deserves the same advocacy SHRM gives to HR
You can stay up to date by following us on LinkedIn, or catch up on previous episodes here.
We’d love for you to help us spread the word about the VideoMy Pod to attract new experts and practitioners to share their activation strategies and help us continue to build this wonderful community. Please subscribe wherever you listen or give us a share on LinkedIn!
If you’re ready to level up your activation strategy, we help organisations turn moments that matter into stories that people trust. Interested in learning more? Book a walkthrough with one of our video specialists.
Welcome to the VideoMy Podcast series where we go two inches wide and a mile deep on employee brand recruitment marketing and internal comms. I'm David Macciocca and joining me for this US series is co-host Bryan Chaney, founder of People Nerd and PBC. Let's get into it.
And I'm Crystal Miller-Lay.
Sure. So, I started my career in marketing many many years ago and uh by accident ended up in recruiting. Uh it's fun story to tell over drinks. probably not the right one for today. But um but when I got into recruiting, I found out really quickly that recruiters and hiring managers and HR teams, they didn't market their jobs. And that was really weird to me as a marketer. Um so I drifted um after doing a quick tour in HR and all the things um I drifted into employer branding and recruitment marketing. I have been in this space since 2004. So for about as long as EB has been like a thing popular. Yeah, I've been I have been working on it. Um I think I still hold the record for the number of communities built professionally. Um my background is beyond professionally and marketing my educational background. I have an MBA from the University of Wales and a masters in psychology. So I am a giant nerd and I am excited to talk to you about all of the nerdiness of communities and why it's important for people today.
Oh. [clears throat] Um, [snorts] I'd love to say I'm naturally a networker. I'm not. So, um, I have to work really hard at that actually. Um, I am curious about people. I love knowing what makes people tick. Mostly, I like knowing what drives behavior. So, what makes people act? So, what's going to get person A to do thing B in space C? That's my thing. That's my jam.
Yeah, that was uh it was interesting. We were both thinking about it at the same time separately and Bryan was like, "Hey, Alice and I have been talking. We want to talk." I was like, "Cool. I wanted to talk to you too." And so we started talking and it was we we both had that same idea of like you know there's there's a SHERM that serves HR and there's SCOP that serves IOC and there's IE E that serves engineering but there's not really a group that serves um employer branding communication AMA serves marketing but people that do the work that we do the the people brand work right like they're the redheaded stepchildren of any group they're in and and probably at work too half the time Right? And that's a really isolating feeling. And so it makes it difficult to create standards and foundations and a sense of community and belonging outside of your your office. And again, if you're a team of one, maybe inside of it. And so we really wanted to address that in in a way that was bigger than a couple of years or a social media platform or a couple of events.
Oh yeah, there's a lot of oneoffs on internal coms.
And when you think about like I want to hit on that loneliness piece for a second because it's really important now like when you think about the sense of isolation that we as people feel and have felt since the pandemic. It it started before the pandemic but it the pandemic really accelerated it. It's pretty significant. Um we don't make friends at the same rate. we're not keeping friends at the same rate. Um, our friendships tend to be more shallow and a lot of that is because adult friendships are often defined by either work or children, right? And so, one of the things that the pandemic did was shift how we work in a really large way. And so, we are isolated more at work than we've ever been. We [snorts] have isolated teams that are small and siloed. And so it makes it more difficult to really form relationships with people, right? Because we we are also working more while all of this is happening. So we are in an epidemic of loneliness. And that's something that you can look up as a psychology thing. It's um it's not just our industry. It's it's every industry. Um but it is particularly I think hitting our industry hard because there are so many people that work remote or hybrid in a solo type team. So they're already isolated in their job. So this I think also solves a little bit of giving people an outlet to build relationships that we really desperately need as people.
Yeah, I so we've joked for years that TA is a solid 10 years behind um traditional market like TA tech is a solid 10 years behind traditional marketing, right? I think to some degree uh that holds true for team structures as well. uh when you look at like where we're at compared to where marketing teams were 10-15 years ago, it's it's pretty similar. You know, you're you're seeing some maturation models um occurring in larger organizations and some mid-size companies, but there's still a lot of onesie twoosies that are asked to be generalists and do all of the things and you know, companies that don't really quite get the importance. Like they know it's important, but they don't really know why it's important and so they're not necessarily investing the way that they need to. um in people and resources and all of the things, right? And when that happens, um I think you see a lot of what we saw yesterday where you've got maybe some really large companies with one or two people that are expected to to move the world, right? Um and that's okay. I that's where marketing was, you know, 1015 years ago. There were giant companies that I worked with where their marketing department was five people and you would never know it, right? They're multi-billion dollar companies with a five person marketing team.
Well, it's almost like gladiator moments, right? Like I think about um I don't know if you ever watched Scandal, but man, I I fell in love with large wine glasses because of it. But I I digress. Um they talked about being gladiators in suits, right? Because they had to go accomplish all of these crazy things and fight all of these different things. like it was always a battle. It feels very much like the modern um EB and then sometimes the modern internal comms, right? Like I've got to get your support. I've got to get your cooperation. And I know you don't necessarily want to stop or slow down or do this or give me this stuff, but you got to and here's why you got to and here's why it's important. And and we I want to work with you and I want to partner with you. It's the you know, I'm going to I'm going to put on my armor and I'm going to grab my sword. I'm going to fight the good fight and we're going to get there. And I think by and large we we do eventually. Um but I think that's exhausting and and lonely in and of itself, right? Because if you have to constantly fight to get to where you need to be, it's tiring.
Yeah. I mean, just like companies, we talk a lot about how companies aren't really all that different from each other, right? Um, and everybody wants to think that they're special and they're different and they're unique. They're not, right? There's there's the what's the joke? There's like 11 story lines in the in the world or something to that extent, right? people have repeatable patterns, a lot of things in common. And so it is comforting when we do have the ability to recognize that in each other. I think it it's a good thing. Um I think it's also a good thing to be able to recognize that our companies have these same issues and problems and that these things that feel maybe insurmountable to us in our organizations like, oh yeah, so and so's dealing with that too or oh yeah, so and so dealt with that last year and here's how they got past it. And I think that's part of the real power of PBC is that shared knowledge. Um you know Chatham House rules obviously what happens in PBC is is stays in PBC. Um George is like Vegas in that way. Yeah. But cleaner. Um so so um posher. There we go. I don't know. Anyway um I might want to edit that out. But that said stay in posh community. There we go. But um but that that said, right, I think that's part of the power of it is that it's not unlike a conference or just a journal or something. It's not certification. Yeah. A certification or course that ends. It's not like okay, we're going to give you this predetermined set of knowledge and when we're done we're done, right? It's a living organic um constantly evolving set of knowledge from people who are very much in your shoes and if not exactly in your place right in your position in your shoes and and I I say that and Brian you may want to jump in here too um because I think one of the the areas where we differ from a lot of communities and organizations is we don't treat anyone doing the work differently because they do it in a different type of company. And so what I mean by that is when we sat down and said, "All right, what do we want PPC to look like? There were a couple of things that were really important to I think to all of us, but especially to me. Um, and one of that is that we were not exclusionary to agency or um vendors and our vendor solution partners um and an agency." And I am agency, right? But I've I've been on both sides of that desk, right? I have been an in-house practitioner. I have been a consultant. Oh, no, no, no. But I think it's important in context, right? So, I've been an in-house practitioner. I mean, I've run HR. It was not my jam. I gained over 100 pounds. Do not recommend that for people like me, but a lot of people do it really well and it's great. Not my jam. Uh, I've been a consultant. Like, that's a really interesting job, too. It is very hard. I have a lot of respect for people who do that. And now I own and run an agency, right? And so, I'm on that side of the world. And so, I've been in all of those seats. Um, my husband has been a um he's worked for a vendor. Um, it's like I've seen all of it, but it's interesting to see when you're not that in-house practitioner how shunted you get from our industry, right? Like you've got to pay more to be able to go to conferences to get the same learning opportunities that someone who's an in-house practitioner gets because conferences are supported by vendors. And, you know,
And I think that's something that's something that's not just I think it's important to note that's not something that's just specific to agency or vendors, right? Consultants do it too. And and in fact, you know, my husband and I laugh about it a lot. It's called consultant speak. and you stop saying I and you start saying us and we and so we think we are us, you know, together it it's a way to actually create connection with your clients, right? But if you are agency or you are a consultant or you are a solutions provider and you've been doing that for a while, like it becomes second nature. And so yeah, you know, yesterday when that came up, it was like, hey, you're going to get deemed for selling. Someone's going to feel like you're selling to them and that's probably not your intent. You're probably consultant speaking. And so some of that is an opportunity to teach, you know, the industry like it's okay to be you, right? Because we do, I think, get to a place where we forget like you individually have value. I have value. Brian has value. You have value as individuals, not just the collective. We us.
It's an important one though because when you think about who ends up in agency consultants um and and in the tech space in the vendor space it is disproportionately people who are at a disadvantage right um either because they're a minority um which is shouldn't be a disadvantage right but we there's so much data that says that it is right like they don't get the same um they don't get the same thought at the same opportunities that who's that a minority? Sorry. Uh- minorities. Um, so that might be women, that might be people of color, that might be people with disabilities. Um, that might be the neurode divergent, right? I was getting there. So, so um, and I kind of go because I know, you know, um, there's several groups in there that are like, hey, I don't like being classified as the minority. And truthfully, when you put the dis uh the uh people with disabilities and the neurody divergent together, they are the majority of the world and and yet they are the minority of the working world. And so there's um they don't get the same opportunities to work in corporate spaces. Um they are uh twothirds more likely to be put on a PIP in the first year. They're more likely to be fired. Um there's a lot more intractability in employment with that group. And so they end up in spaces that um
and and so they end up in these places and spaces like agencies and tech and then we go back to what I was saying before then they're penalized further for being in those spaces by not getting the same learning opportunities that the people who are in corporate roles practitioner roles are able to get. Yeah. So, we did want to do that.
Yeah. Well, and it's equal membership. So, it's not like and I say that because um I don't know if we have that in this space, but in some of the other industries uh that I touched, right, because I'm also in marketing, I'm also in that psychology space. you you can be an associate member or a junior member or a vendor member and it's like you get a reduced uh you can get in the room where it happens but you can't speak and and maybe you don't get in all the rooms right it's like uh Indeed connect right you can go to Indeed connect but you can't go to all of these tracks right you can go to these general sessions but you can't go to the cool cool sessions and that's not that's a weird feeling Okay.
So,
Yeah. It's to to us or in the conversations that we've had and the conversations with the board, it's it's not just about, hey, we want to provide a space or a couple of events. Like, we're not an events company, right? Like, we we have events. Had a pretty good event yesterday. Thank you. Uh that's Brian. Um but that said like that's not our that's not our mission. Our mission is to advance our industry. And so when we talk about that we're talking about things like creating standards and and some clarity, right? There are how many job titles in our industry? Over 200. Right? And so you know that can become very confusing for companies and it makes it difficult to understand the value. Um so creating some baselines, creating some um something like ISO standard if not ISO itself that that type of standard that allows companies to understand like here's the bare minimum, here's what we recommend, you know, here's the companies that are really knocking it out apart like so they can see some examples um in a way that isn't just a white paper or a case study that's been paid for by a vendor. What if there was one platform specifically built to streamline the entire employee content life cycle? Meet Video My AI powered content intelligence platform [music] for enterprise teams to create authentic employee content at scale. Automate every step of the process. Video makes it easy to plan and launch campaigns and capture authentic employee video stories from anywhere in the world with an easy filming experience. Then let our AI transform every employee video into an entire library of content assets from social posts and blogs to quote cards, emails, and more. Share authentic employee stories across every channel. Reach more people and make every piece of content work harder. Our enterprise analytics helps you understand engagement and optimize your next campaign. Power every employee story with Video My AI powered content intelligence platform for employee generated content. Book a demo at video.co.
So many things.
I mean, so there's there's different pieces of success, right? And so when you look at the community piece of it, that's a numbers game and and Dunar uh Dunar's social theory. Uh it's actually about gorillas, believe it or not, but it's it's the most solid um baseline research for community success. And so, you know, when you have your seven super users, your 13 original users, your seven super users, you know, your 100 lurkers and all the things, right? There's there's numbers that tell you, yeah, okay, your community is going to work. This is good. Um, so we can watch those. What what I think the deeper success is is some of the things we started to hear yesterday, which is like, hey, I I am using this community to help me learn. I am taking this back because I don't have resources and so this is really important to me because it's the only way I get to learn right um when we are able to put out research that says okay here's how I think our first research is actually around AI but you know I've got a full research map that I want to be able to put out with an actual journal of okay this is what we need to know here are the updates that you know people in our profession need to know and understandable Well, it's changing. So, yeah, it is. It is.
Yeah. So, I mean, so, so when we're able to get to the place that we can do those things and and not only the day-to-day, which is absolutely what you should be doing in the first couple of years of an association, like to me, that's the deeper success, right?
And so I think some of how we work through that is is really how things have been done over the last few years. You start online, you get that that ground swell, right, that says yes, there's enough interest to be able to do something in person. Um, and then you go. But in the meantime, we do have a couple of different ways that we're able to help service members all over the world. One is we have a great partnership with social talent. And so we're able to curate um not only their content, but content specifically into that social talent system for learning um which can be used by everyone all over the world, which is awesome. Uh the platform that we use also has learning opportunities that we can build into it. So that's cool. And then we have our member calls that we're able to set up at any time of the day. So we can actually help um service different time zones, right? We just have to say, "Okay, member, you know, David, you're in Australia. We want you to to like host a member call." Like, "Are you down for that?" And if you are, then great. You know, otherwise, one of us are waking up at like, I don't know, 3 in the morning, whatever. So it it it works. But which is fine. We can do that every once in a while, but but ideally all of these different regions have some self-sustaining pockets of people that are like, "Yeah, yeah, yeah. We want to get in and we want to share what we're doing, too." So then the US is sharing with Australia and Australia is sharing with the UK and the UK is sharing with APAC and everyone's learning together. And that that's the goal and that's the that's the dream.
Well, how do you fit it in? Time block. Time blocking is a beautiful thing. No. Um, so I think people make time for the things that are important to them and that have benefit for them. And so I think the first thing is understanding, well, what's the benefit in it? Like the with them, what's in it for me? Yeah. And one of the things that I think that we have to look at is like sherm for example the the benefit of sherm to people who are in HR is not that it dictates what shall or shall not be done in HR and that's a little silly right but what it does do is it creates and shares here is baseline what's happening everywhere right like here's the standard here's the baseline here's the standards that are there but it also advocates for people not just the discipline itself it does that too like it lobbies for the discipline but it advocates for the people within it right to help advance those people care for those people that have made their profession within HR we need that from our discipline right because we don't have that there's there's pieces of that for talent acquisition there's pieces of that for HR there's pieces of that for marketing but not for people who work in people brand and communications and and we deserve that frankly um and not only do we deserve that our businesses need it. And so I think having this association really does allow for us to be able to share those best practices, right, and create those baselines, but also have an organization that has your back.
Oh, it was an absolute pleasure. Thanks for unpacking the benefit of community. Thank you. [music]




